AngleSharp isn't supported or required for integration testing of ASP.NET Core apps. The integration test plan document is approved, signed off, and documented. For more information, see the Customize WebApplicationFactory section. Here are the six most popular forms of integration testing. The following test class, BasicTests, uses the WebApplicationFactory to bootstrap the SUT and provide an HttpClient to a test method, Get_EndpointsReturnSuccessAndCorrectContentType. The only way you can discover problems that show up in testing is by logging your test results. The process described here is somewhat sequential, but is also iterative and evolving since new information will likely emerge throughout the life cycle of an application. Integration testing is based on following the standard, but can also test in a negative way to see where the standard may not be followed. The TestAuthHandler is called to authenticate a user when the authentication scheme is set to Test where AddAuthentication is registered for ConfigureTestServices. The Top 10 Slack Integrations You Should Try, Bridging The Gap Between HIPAA & Cloud Computing: What You Need To Know Today, What is Integration Testing: Examples, Challenges, and Approaches, Become a full stack developer in 6 months, In Partnership with HIRIST and HackerEarth, Learn Git Command, Angular, NodeJS, Maven & More, Cloud Architect Certification Training Course, DevOps Engineer Certification Training Course, Big Data Hadoop Certification Training Course, AWS Solutions Architect Certification Training Course, Certified ScrumMaster (CSM) Certification Training, ITIL 4 Foundation Certification Training Course, Incompatibility between software modules can cause errors, Developers must confirm that every software module can interact with the database, Requirements change, thanks to client input. 2. Verify that all the read and unread emails are displayed in the inbox. So, dont delay; visit Simplilearn today and make your full-stack developer career a reality! It also verifies a software system's coexistence with . Check if the user who has logged in has a session time out or not, 9. Testing is cool, but before an application is tested, it must first be coded. The execution order is a breaking change for the Generic Host with the release of ASP.NET Core 3.0. Verify that the recently received email or unread emails are highlighted in bold in the Inbox section. Modules at a lower level are tested inadequately. Any scenarios can be called as integration scenario only if the data gets saved in the destination. One of the most interesting findings was that of the 109 reports that are detailed, 98% showed that the problem could have been detected by testing the device with all pairs of parameter settings.. A basic definition, Interoperability Testing vs Integration Testing. One of the primary ways integration is achieved today is through Application Programming Interfaces (APIs). To view or add a comment, sign in. Using a test plan for integration testing, Integration Testing Example with PractiTest, More Integration Testing Examples With Interoperability Testing, ACTS (Automated Combinatorial Testing for Software). Contains a test method for routing and content type. I strive to provide well-researched information on the leading market savvy technologies. Integration tests Plan, test case, scenarios to be signed off and documented. A test runner is used to execute the tests and report the test results. Integration testing shows the team how well these disparate elements work together. The development team deployed Invoices, a new functional block of the ERP system. In essence, this is end-to-end testing that spans systems. This is better than point-to-point integration in terms of complexity, but it relies upon all parties following the standard. This fact means they can find bugs and integration issues sooner, ensuring a faster release to the public. Many of my clients have faced a common problem, which is the ability to test integration and interoperability in a system of systems context. This is important to understand because both integration and interoperability testing are typically needed to fully validate how software behaves when a transfer of data or control occurs. Once a user has logged in, it should be displayed that the user has logged into the Facebook page, 2. The method checks if the response status code is successful (status codes in the range 200-299) and the Content-Type header is text/html; charset=utf-8 for several app pages. View or download sample code (how to download). For more information, see the blog Integration Testing ASP.NET Core Resources Protected with Antiforgery Using Application Parts and associated GitHub repo by Martin Costello. Following are the Integration test scenarios for a Facebook application: 1. A typical software project consists of multiple software modules, coded by different programmers. Below are the different strategies, the way they are executed and their limitations as well advantages. The required test environment has been set up for integration testing. Changing the test port. Once a user has logged in, it should be displayed that the user has logged into the Facebook page. For testing the endpoints of controller and Razor Pages views at a lower-level, without caring about how they render in the browser, consider using Application Parts. To use a different database for the tests, the app's database context must be replaced in builder.ConfigureServices. Use the actual components that the app uses in production. For example, a delete test calls for a database record deletion, so the database must have at least one record for the delete request to succeed. Integration testing involves testing various modules of the software under development as a group to see whether they function together seamlessly. However, by applying combinatorial approaches and workflow scenarios, it may be possible to lessen the risk of integration failures. You can read more about the Pyramid and why we use it here. The team had to assure that the invoice unit was able to process queries from the ERP system. Integration Testing becomes necessary to verify the software modules work in unity. a test scenario is a description of a task a user might perform within the program and a test script is a comprehensive description of the . However, this knowledge is often missing or limited which leads to untested interfaces and missed defects. For SUTs that still use the Web Host, the test app's builder.ConfigureServices callback is executed before the SUT's Startup.ConfigureServices code. Accessing a secure page by an authenticated user with a mock. Tools such as Postman and SoapUI can provide a helpful framework for defining and performing API tests, but there is still a need to manage and report API tests. If using Visual Studio Code or the command line, execute the following command at a command prompt in the tests/RazorPagesProject.Tests directory: The SUT is a Razor Pages message system with the following characteristics: The EF article, Test with InMemory, explains how to use an in-memory database for tests with MSTest. Test Implementation - This is where you create test cases and procedures, along with the test data to support the tests. Test concepts and test implementations across different test frameworks are similar but not identical. The IWebHostBuilder allows the configuration of the service collection with IWebHostBuilder.ConfigureServices. Figure 6 Point to Point Integration Between Systems. Because the Microsoft.AspNetCore.Mvc.Testing package is used to configure the test host and test server, the TestHost and TestServer packages don't require direct package references in the test app's project file or developer configuration in the test app. Another approach is to write code to handle the antiforgery system's request verification token and antiforgery cookie directly. The Integration test procedure irrespective of the Software testing strategies (discussed above): Entry and Exit Criteria to Integration testing phase in any software development model, Copyright - Guru99 2022 Privacy Policy|Affiliate Disclaimer|ToS, Brief Description of Integration Test Plans, Entry and Exit Criteria of Integration Testing, Best Practices/ Guidelines for Integration Testing, Boundary Value Analysis and Equivalence Partitioning Testing, What is Defect Density? Let's briefly understand how Integration testing works with the help of two real-life scenarios. Other domains which also have the need for integration testing which reach almost impossible levels of test condition combinations include automotive (especially with emerging autonomous vehicle technologies), avionics, financial and the Internet of Things (IoT). Testing functions in isolation is important, but falls short of testing software behavior in ways it will actually be used in conjunction with other items. Infrastructure components, such as the test web host and in-memory test server (TestServer), are provided or managed by the Microsoft.AspNetCore.Mvc.Testing package. Create the WebApplicationFactoryClientOptions class and pass it to the CreateClient() method (default values are shown in the code example): Services can be overridden in a test with a call to ConfigureTestServices on the host builder. The Microsoft.AspNetCore.Mvc.Testing package handles the following tasks: The unit tests documentation describes how to set up a test project and test runner, along with detailed instructions on how to run tests and recommendations for how to name tests and test classes. Unlike the bottom-up method, the top-down approach tests the higher-level modules first, working the way down to the lower-level modules. This leaves the need to include other techniques which we explore in this article. The test project has a reference to the SUT. Create the WebApplicationFactoryClientOptions class and pass it to the CreateClient() method: Services can be overridden in a test with a call to ConfigureTestServices on the host builder. 1. The higher level modules are tested first and then lower level modules are tested and integrated in order to check the software functionality. Make a Tests Plan for your integration testing; Prepare Test Scenarios, Cases, and Scripts. The main objective of SIT is to ensure that all software module dependencies are functioning properly and that data integrity is preserved between distinct modules of the whole system. The test app is a console app inside the tests/RazorPagesProject.Tests directory. Once the lower level modules are tested and integrated, then the next level of modules are formed. However, maybe those new requirements haven't been thoroughly tested yet and should be, There may be potential problems with hardware compatibility, Modules often interact with third-party APIs or tools, so we need integration testing to verify that the data these tools accept is correct, Integration testing ensures that every integrated module functions correctly, Integration testing uncovers interface errors, Testers can initiate integration testing once a module is completed and doesnt require waiting for another module to be done and ready for testing, Testers can detect bugs, defects, and security issues, Integration testing provides testers with a comprehensive analysis of the whole system, dramatically reducing the likelihood of severe connectivity issues, If testing involves dealing with two different systems created by two different vendors, there will be questions about how these components will affect and interact with each other, Integrating new and legacy systems demands many testing efforts and potential changes, Integration testing becomes complex due to the variety of components involved (e.g., platforms, environments, databases), Integration testing requires testing not only the integration links but the environment itself, adding another layer of complexity to the process, First, dont initiate integration testing until each module has undergone functional testing first, Module testing should follow an accepted sequence not to overlook any integration scenarios, Agree on a test case strategy to prepare and execute test cases in conjunction with the test data, Study the applications architecture and structure, identifying the most important modules to be tested first. After the login . The main difference is the level at which integration is tested. While combinatorial testing is helpful and promising, it does have limitations in that it can be somewhat random how the condition combinations are derived. Incremental Approach, in turn, is carried out by two different Methods: Stubs and Drivers are the dummy programs in Integration testing used to facilitate the software testing activity. Follow-up Testing This is where follow-up testing such as confirmation testing and regression testing are performed as changes are made to the components and systems. Integration tests in ASP.NET Core require the following: Integration tests follow a sequence of events that include the usual Arrange, Act, and Assert test steps: Usually, the test web host is configured differently than the app's normal web host for the test runs. If a behavior can be tested using either a unit test or an integration test, choose the unit test. The Integration test strategy should be prepared thoughtfully so that it can be adopted and later the test data and test cases can be prepared accordingly, 2. The validation messages should be checked to know whether they are correctly displayed based on the input values or not, 5. Also, test and operational environments are defined and the needed test tools are acquired and implemented. A test level that focuses on interactions between components or systems. (ISTQB Glossary), The ability of two or more systems or components to exchange information and to use the information that has been exchanged." Helps ensure that infrastructure testing components aren't accidentally included in the unit tests. How SAS Supports Enterprise Stress Testing. These new requirements may not be unit tested and hence system integration Testing becomes necessary. Integration Testing focuses on checking data communication amongst these modules. If all of the components in the unit are not completed, the integration process will not execute. 5. The SUT's database context is registered in its Startup.ConfigureServices method. Send bug reports to the developers, have them fix the errors, then conduct testing again, Offers test plans and test coverage documentation, Automates approval evidence and software certification, Provides seamless execution of integration and unit testing, Provides common environment support suitable for integration testing for many different projects, Performs testing from the perspective of the end-user, Ideal for end-to-end integration and dynamic web application testing, Allows you to execute multiple instances of an application, Supports popular programming languages such as C and C++, Multiple users can access the tool through just one license, Provides test case reusability suitable for regression testing, Automatic stubs and drivers code generation, Integrates well with multiple tools like Green Hills and IBM Rational, Integration testing scopes and out-of-scopes items. Web host configuration can be created independently of the test classes by inheriting from WebApplicationFactory to create one or more custom factories: Inherit from WebApplicationFactory and override ConfigureWebHost. However, lets also consider the situation where the above scenario also triggers a function in a fourth system (D) (Figure 7). Experienced in analyzing and creating Test Plans and Test Cases in Quality Center and Test Manager for various scenarios of end to end functionality testing. This method involves integrating all the modules and components and testing them at once as a single unit. Scenario 1: Check whether the login screens right-click functionality is disabled or not. By Jos van der Til, Martin Costello, and Javier Calvarro Nelson. The quote is embedded in a hidden field on the Index page when the Index page is requested. To that end, today, we are focusing on one specific aspect of testing: integration testing. 5. AngleSharp isn't supported or required for integration testing of ASP.NET Core apps. Accessing a secure page by an unauthenticated user. The test data should not be selected while the test cases are being executed. There are two major levels of integration testing, component integration testing (sometimes called low-level integration testing) as seen in Figure 2 and system integration testing (sometimes called high-level integration testing) seen in Figure 3. In this approach, integration occurs when all the components are in the same architectural domain. Integration testing involves checking individual components or units of a software project to expose defects and problems to verify that they work together as designed. It involves simultaneously testing top-level modules with lower-level modules and integrating lower-level modules with top-level modules, and testing them as a system. About the author: I am a technical content writer focused on writing technology specific articles. In testing the workflows, you automatically cover the integration points and also validate interoperability. The main idea of Test Scenarios is the following. System Integration Testing (SIT) is the overall testing of the whole system which is composed of many sub-systems. The architecture design of the application should be properly studied and the critical modules should be identified. The test framework is xUnit. At the scenario level, it might be possible to test the same coverage of interfaces with a fraction of the test cases needed at the detailed level. To preserve non-essential cookies, such as those used by the TempData provider, mark them as essential in your tests. Hence it is also termed as I & T (Integration and Testing), String Testing and sometimes Thread Testing. By default, non-essential cookies aren't preserved across requests when the General Data Protection Regulation consent policy is enabled. The process continues until all modules at top level are tested. SUT (System Under Test) can be comprised of . In unit tests, the use of infrastructure fakes or mocks result in faster test execution. The point of the combinatorial techniques for integration testing is to deal with extremely high numbers of possible combinations of test conditions. Selecting the first delete button of the messages form in the SUT is simulated in the request to the SUT: See the WebApplicationFactoryClientOptions page for defaults and available options when creating HttpClient instances. After all, each unit may function perfectly on its own, but the pressing question is, But can they be brought together and work smoothly?. The test app's builder.ConfigureServices callback is executed after the app's Startup.ConfigureServices code is executed. Steps 3 and 4 are repeated until the completion of Integration is successful. The username and password field values should be checked to know whether they can be copied or not. Test Scenarios. Integration tests ensure that an app's components function correctly at a level that includes the app's supporting infrastructure, such as the database, file system, and network. ASP.NET Core supports integration tests using a unit test framework with a test web host and an in-memory test server. An example of this need for integration testing is in the domain of medical devices. Besides his volume of work in the gaming industry, he has written articles for Inc.Magazine and Computer Shopper, as well as software reviews for ZDNet. Scopes and Out of Scopes Items of Integration Testing. Without further ado, lets start things with a definition. Separate unit tests from integration tests into different projects. . The test app's builder.ConfigureServices callback is executed after the app's Startup.ConfigureServices code is executed. At least thirty-eight papers and presentations have been published since that date. Focus on project methodology. Therefore, if a service or other component complies with the architecture, integration is assumed. Protractor enjoys support in many different browsers, including Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer, and Safari. After this, other related modules are gradually introduced and integrated until all the logically related modules are successfully tested. Test concepts and test implementations across different test frameworks are similar but not identical. What are the different types of integration testing? Test Basis for Integration Testing. Since all modules are tested at once, high-risk critical modules are not isolated and tested on priority. The problem arises when point-to-point integration is the primary means of integration. Heres a sample. This is a significant finding because it suggests that if we could at least test all the pairs of related conditions, we could test where many of the integration defects reside. In order to arrange for a test's POST request, the test app must: The SendAsync helper extension methods (Helpers/HttpClientExtensions.cs) and the GetDocumentAsync helper method (Helpers/HtmlHelpers.cs) in the sample app use the AngleSharp parser to handle the antiforgery check with the following methods: AngleSharp is a third-party parsing library used for demonstration purposes in this article and the sample app. Now execute the test cases followed by reporting of defects. Allows control over which set of tests are run. API testing may appear to be straightforward, but it can be rather challenging due to inadequate documentation of the interface. The sample app finds the service descriptor for the database context and uses the descriptor to remove the service registration. Once all the lower-level modules are successfully tested and integrated, the next level of modules is formed. Also, identify every possible scenario, Design test cases that will create detailed interface verification, Input data is vital to conducting reliable integration testing, so choose test case execution input data wisely, Generate reports on any bugs found. This is where test management tools such as PractiTest are needed. There are some key ways to achieve integration in computing systems. The sample app finds the service descriptor for the database context and uses the descriptor to remove the service registration. An example of this is shown in Figure 6. Following are the Integration test scenarios for a Facebook application: 1. By default, non-essential cookies aren't preserved across requests when the GDPR consent policy is enabled. It deals with the verification of the high and low-level software requirements specified in the Software Requirements Specification/Data and the Software Design Document. A comprehensive solution, focusing on integration, orchestration, workflows and governance. Executing the test Cases followed by reporting the defects. Research in software testing interactions goes back at least 35 years when some of the first papers were published on the topic of using combinatorial techniques for software testing. We normally do Integration testing after "Unit testing". CreateClient() creates an instance of HttpClient that automatically follows redirects and handles cookies. Component integration testing example: Invoice unit + ERP system. ideally in integration testing you will testing integration between modules FI, MM, AA, SD etc., or you can be testing some interfaces. Dont choose test data when youre running test cases. The ability to adequately test integration and interoperability depend on the ability to know where the integration exists. Interfaces of the software modules with the database could be erroneous, External Hardware interfaces, if any, could be erroneous. The user should be able to log in successfully after providing a valid username and password, 3. Heres an example of integrating testing involving a website that features Log-in Page, Mailbox, and Delete E-mails functions. All the integration test cases have been successfully executed. It also uses stubs and drivers to create missing modules to simulate code functionality. All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Sitemap, We use cookies to improve performance and enhance your experience. . Shadow copying causes the tests to execute in a different directory than the output directory. This integration testing uses test drivers to drive and pass appropriate data to the lower level . In this article, you will get to know about the test scenarios for integration testing. Otherwise, authentication won't work. Each of the test levels has a Test Basis which should be referred to create scenarios for that test level. The test data should be properly used as planned. Expose the implicitly defined Program class to the test project by doing one of the following: Expose internal types from the web app to the test project. Before execution, the mock data should be prepared. Design test scenarios and scripts. Design the Test Scenarios, Cases, and Scripts. Track and re-test defects as soon as they arise. Some testing strategies work better with specific development projects. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy, What is integration testing? As an example, integration testing can show what happens when data is sent from one component to another. At the component level, there are many conditions to consider which lead to higher numbers of tests. Other parsers can be used, such as the Html Agility Pack (HAP). Much of this is due to a lack of documentation or knowledge about where integration occurs in this point-to-point approach. The main function or goal of this testing is to test the interfaces between the units/modules. One proven way I deal with this problem is to focus testing on workflow scenarios (Figure 9). In addition, you will learn Angular, Spring Boot, web services, JSPs, and MongoDB, valuable tools needed to launch your career as a full-stack developer. If you are attempting integration testing, keep these guidelines in mind: Developers can use many different accepted software testing techniques in integration testing. See this GitHub repository for basic tests of authentication middleware. So, it is actually components that are passing data and control between each other, spanning systems. The tester can use either the top-down or bottom-up methods. Unfortunately, integration testing has some difficulties to overcome as well. Integration tests are conducted using the Microsoft.AspNetCore.TestHost, which includes the TestServer. Perhaps these interfaces are all known to a tester so they perform the tests and see that integration and interoperability is achieved correctly. Click here if the video is not accessible. Inadequate exception handling could cause issues. To use a different database for the tests than the app's database, the app's database context must be replaced in builder.ConfigureServices. PMP, PMI, PMBOK, CAPM, PgMP, PfMP, ACP, PBA, RMP, SP, and OPM3 are registered marks of the Project Management Institute, Inc. *According to Simplilearn survey conducted and subject to. Ahead, we'll take a closer look at integration testing and why it's important. A good integration test plan has the following attributes: Here are the criteria that should be met before starting integration testing and before ending it. NIST has a free tool called ACTS (Automated Combinatorial Testing for Software) that generates test cases based on n-wise testing. The integration and interoperability wasnt tested because no one considered system D was even part of the picture. Post Graduate Program in Full Stack Web Development. Upgrade to Microsoft Edge to take advantage of the latest features, security updates, and technical support. These elements are dummy programs used in integration testing to facilitate software testing activity, acting as substitutes for any missing models in the testing process. These prerequisites can be seen in the sample app. After the test cases, its the test data which plays the critical role. This is a context where combinatorial methods, such as pairwise testing, are helpful to reduce the number of tests. Automated test scenario management: Test Management tools can be used as storage for your automated test scenarios. Integration tests Plan, test case, scenarios to be signed off and documented. Use of this package streamlines test creation and execution. Don't write integration tests for every permutation of data and file access with databases and file systems. "SUT" is used throughout this article to refer to the ASP.NET Core app being tested. This may not be a valid assumption. If a specific post has been liked and that specific post is accessed through another user/group, then the like should be displayed. It's important for the Test scheme to match the scheme your app expects. Expose internal types from the web app to the test project. 5. It should be tested on a priority basis, 3. More recently, he has done extensive work as a professional blogger. WebApplicationFactory is used to create a TestServer for the integration tests. In Figure 4 we see how these levels of integration can be achieved in a pyramid-like approach. Following on from my article series on Unit Testing, this article will discuss the virtues of API . Bottom-up Integration Testing is a strategy in which the lower level modules are tested first. Then the other related modules are integrated incrementally and the process continues until all the logically related modules are integrated and tested successfully. This article provides a more detailed guide, with examples, on using specific methods for incremental testing together.. Required Test Environment . Let's have a look at the test basis for Integration Testing: And also if you don't want to miss out on any integration scenarios then you have to follow the proper sequence. . Since the Integration testing can commence only after all the modules are designed, the testing team will have less time for execution in the testing phase. Integration testing involves checking individual components or units of a software project to expose defects and problems to verify that they work together as designed. This test performs a record delete in the database by triggering a form submission in the SUT. Stub: Is called by the Module under Test. Let's see the possible test cases for Gmail Inbox functionality. Integration testing aims to test the interfaces between the modules and expose any faults that may arise while the components are integrated. The sample app seeds the database with three messages in Utilities.cs that tests can use when they execute: The SUT's database context is registered in Program.cs. This is not an isolated finding and it gives support to the idea of testing related functions, such as in the case of integration testing, with techniques such as pairwise testing to help manage the very high number of possible interactions that could possibly be tested. Similarly Mail Box: Check its integration to the Delete Mails Module. The method is described in the Integration tests sample: Test app organization section. Chosen e-mail is sent to the Deleted/Trash folder. If the unread notification has been displayed then click on Notification so that there is a decrease in the Notification unread count, 4. Because another test in the IndexPageTests class performs an operation that deletes all of the records in the database and may run before the Post_DeleteMessageHandler_ReturnsRedirectToRoot method, the database is reseeded in this test method to ensure that a record is present for the SUT to delete. The duration of the login time should be ascertained, 10. Before you begin integration testing, keep the following best practices in mind. Interactions with different parts of the system such as hardware, file system and operating system along with interfaces between components are tested using the Integration testing method. 2. Separating the tests: There's virtually no difference between the configuration for tests of Razor Pages apps and MVC apps. It makes use of both stubs as well as drivers. ETL Test Scenarios : Test Description : Record Level Scenarios: These are record level ETL tests: Record Count Testing: This is a primary test, to check if all the available records are populated - Nothing more, nothing less. If unfamiliar with test concepts, see the Unit Testing in .NET Core and .NET Standard topic and its linked content. See the project file in GitHub. The sample app is a Razor Pages app and assumes a basic understanding of Razor Pages. It is in this activity that testing efforts are coordinated with affected parties. Figure 9 Focusing testing on workflow scenarios. The test app's builder.ConfigureServices callback is executed after the app's Program.cs code is executed. Each integration scenarios should compulsorily have source datadestination. Validate the log-in and the mailboxs module interface link, Enter the required log-in credentials and click the log-in button, Validate the mailbox and the Delete Mails Module interface links, Select an e-mail from the mailbox, then click on "delete.". Early methods were based in Latin squares which is another name for orthogonal arrays. While designing the test cases and test scenarios, it . This article uses the AngleSharp parser to handle the antiforgery checks by loading pages and parsing the HTML. Example Test Cases, Check the interface link between the Login and Mailbox module, Enter login credentials and click on the Login button, Check the interface link between the Mailbox and Delete Mails Module, From Mailbox select the email and click a delete button, Selected email should appear in the Deleted/Trash folder, A Module, in general, is designed by an individual software developer whose understanding and programming logic may differ from other programmers. The purpose of this level of testing is to expose defects in the interaction between these software modules when they are integrated. You will also learn how to design tests that can deal with the high levels of complexity often seen in highly integrated system architectures. The process continues until every top-level module is tested. Test Execution In this activity you conduct and evaluate tests along with reporting incidents as failures are seen. A minimal scenario returns an AuthenticateResult.Success: The TestAuthHandler is called to authenticate a user when the authentication scheme is set to TestScheme where AddAuthentication is registered for ConfigureTestServices. Select the most appropriate testing approach and identify test conditions according to the data flow. However, once we start to design and perform tests based on integration, the complexity that arises from many points of integration can increase the number of possible tests to massive numbers. System B may in turn call a function in another system (C). Specify the Web SDK in the project file (. To be in the architecture, components must follow the same rules for integration. Integration tests evaluate an app's components on a broader level than unit tests. This problem is often seen when integration is present between related functions, components, and/or systems, and when the combined test conditions would yield far too many possible test cases to realistically implement and perform. "SUT" is used throughout this . Otherwise, authentication won't work. Following are the Integration test scenarios for a Gmail application: 1. Unit tests are used to test isolated software components, such as individual class methods. While test planning may be out of style in some organizations, there is still a strong need for such planning especially where integration is concerned. unlike Unit testing (which specfic TCode or a step), integration testing attempts to test steps in a logical order. At this point, a failure occurs. To override the SUT's environment when using IHostBuilder: If the SUT uses the Web Host (IWebHostBuilder), override CreateWebHostBuilder: The EF topic, Test with InMemory, explains how to use an in-memory database for tests with MSTest. Parse the antiforgery cookie and request validation token from the response. In discussions of integration tests, the tested project is frequently called the System Under Test, or "SUT" for short. Integration Test Case differs from other test cases in the sense it focuses mainly on the interfaces & flow of data/information between the modules. When additional configuration is required within a test method, WithWebHostBuilder creates a new WebApplicationFactory with an IWebHostBuilder that is further customized by configuration. The test project creates a test web host for the SUT and uses a test server client to handle requests and responses with the SUT. So, developers need to release software and apps that have undergone thorough, rigorous testing. Sample Integration Test Cases for the following scenario: Application has 3 modules say Login Page, Mailbox and Delete emails and each of them is integrated logically. Integration tests usually require a small dataset in the database prior to the test execution. Citrus is an open-source testing framework ideal for complex integration testing. Before the actual coding is done, a basic test strategy deciding the test cases and test data used . Interface to database/external hardware/software application must be tested in detail. The Automation Testing Pyramid is something we use to describe the most effective and efficient way for just about any business wanting to use Test Automation for Quality Assurance. The factory then adds a new ApplicationDbContext that uses an in-memory database for the tests.. To connect to a different database than the in-memory database, change the UseInMemoryDatabase call to connect the context to a different database. Successful Testing of Integrated Application. Although the app doesn't use the repository pattern and isn't an effective example of the Unit of Work (UoW) pattern, Razor Pages supports these patterns of development. Once a reset button has been clicked, check whether the filled values of the username and password have been cleared or not, 6. If objects instantiated by the developer require disposal, dispose of them in the IClassFixture implementation. Integration benefits. Software testing, both manual and automated, helps ensure quality control and determines how well the software performs. One thing we have learned over the years, supported by credible research, is that software failures are much more likely to manifest where interactions occur. This combined set of components is considered as an entity while testing. It is a combination of Top-down and Bottom-up approaches therefore it is called Hybrid Integration Testing. The app contains a data access layer (DAL) in its database context class. Controlling the test port. Test Implementation This is where you create test cases and procedures, along with the test data to support the tests. . You also gain an economy of testing by taking the scenario view. "SUT" is used throughout this . For more information, see the Customize WebApplicationFactory section. For instructions on marking a cookie as essential, see Essential cookies. Regardless of how many places across an app interact with databases and file systems, a focused set of read, write, update, and delete integration tests are usually capable of adequately testing database and file system components. Pay Attention to the expected result. Rgds. However, bug-ridden software can lead to a catastrophic public relations nightmare and backlash. This topic assumes a basic understanding of unit tests. In a research paper published in 2001 by Delores Wallace and Richard Kuhn of the National Institute of Standards and Technology1, over 15 years of medical device recall report data was analyzed. Critical Modules are tested on priority; major design flaws could be found and fixed first. Verify that the recently received email has correct sender 's name or email id, subject of the email . All High prioritized bugs fixed and closed. . However, interoperability testing is needed to show that the true user need can be achieved in an operational context. In reality, systems integrate at the component level. If testing only pairs of conditions leaves more to be desired, n-wise testing can test 3-wise, 4-wise and higher. On the other hand, system testing tests the entire system, seeing if the system works in harmony with all the integrated modules and components. If the SUT's environment isn't set, the environment defaults to Development. This testing tool works for both unit and integrating testing projects, significantly reducing costs and time by automating much of the testing process. Returns content for an authenticated user. In addition, types of testing can be performed at multiple levels of testing as seen in Figure 1. Other than the fundamental truth that developers must test all software applications before releasing them to the public, there are some specific reasons why developers should perform integration testing. This open-source automation testing tool is designed for web-based application testing. The mock service replaces the app's QuoteService with a service provided by the test app, called TestQuoteService: ConfigureTestServices is called, and the scoped service is registered: The markup produced during the test's execution reflects the quote text supplied by TestQuoteService, thus the assertion passes: Tests in the AuthTests class check that a secure endpoint: In the SUT, the /SecurePage page uses an AuthorizePage convention to apply an AuthorizeFilter to the page. If unfamiliar with Razor Pages, see the following topics: Entity Framework Core is also used in the tests. To test with WebApplicationFactory without a Startup class, an ASP.NET Core 6 app needs to expose the implicitly defined Program class to the test project by doing one of the following: After making the changes in the web application, the test project now can use the Program class for the WebApplicationFactory. Design test scenarios, test cases, and test scripts and perform integration testing after deploying chosen modules. Big Bang Testing is an Integration testing approach in which all the components or modules are integrated together at once and then tested as a unit. It can be a typical software project that is coded by different programmers, and testing is performed on its multiple modules. In addition, Ldra is an open-platform tool that provides code coverage analysis, design reviews, dynamic analysis and static/dynamic analysis, and much more. The meaning of Integration testing is quite straightforward- Integrate/combine the unit tested module one by one and test the behavior as a combined unit. Get an overview of each module's functionality, identify the entry, exit points and prepare the plan for the integration test. Test Reporting This is where test findings are reported, including test status reports and the final test report. If you're unfamiliar with Razor Pages, see the following articles: For testing SPAs, we recommend a tool such as Playwright for .NET, which can automate a browser. After deciding on a testing method, it's time to design various test scenarios and scripts that the team of developers or engineers can use during integration testing. Technical documents to be submitted followed by release Notes. This article defines integration testing, why its needed, the correct approaches, the best integration testing techniques, a look at the tools and practices, and even an example of integration testing. Contains the integration tests for the Index page using custom, Gets or sets the maximum number of redirect responses that. The method verifies the response status code is successful (200-299) and the Content-Type header is text/html; charset=utf-8 for several app pages. The sample app is a Razor Pages app and assumes a basic understanding of Razor Pages. Exposing the defects is the major focus of the integration testing and the time of interaction between the integrated units. Web host configuration can be created independently of the test classes by inheriting from WebApplicationFactory to create one or more custom factories: Inherit from WebApplicationFactory and override ConfigureWebHost. After the login has been successful, the name of the login user should be displayed, 3. The Caltech Coding Bootcamp, ranked the Number One coding bootcamp by Career Karma, can turn you into a full-stack developer in six months! Repeat steps 3 and 4 till Integration testing is successful. Integration Testing is defined as a type of testing where software modules are integrated logically and tested as a group. We came up with an optimization to quickly replay test setups. This can be done in the SUT project's file (.csproj): Make the Program class public using a partial class declaration: The sample app uses the Program partial class approach. What Are Slack Integrations? They do not implement the entire programming logic of the software module but they simulate data communication with the calling module while testing. Track and retest the defects. A typical test uses the HttpClient and helper methods to process the request and the response: Any POST request to the SUT must satisfy the antiforgery check that's automatically made by the app's data protection antiforgery system. If you are using BDD or some keyword-based test automation framework, test scenarios could be stored in your test management tool and fetched directly from there for each execution. Allows a user to add, delete one, delete all, and analyze messages. The password field values must be checked to know whether they are displayed in masked formats like bullets or asterisks, 7. The first response is a redirect in many of these tests with a Location header. More info about Internet Explorer and Microsoft Edge, Unit Testing in .NET Core and .NET Standard, General Data Protection Regulation consent policy, Integration Testing ASP.NET Core Resources Protected with Antiforgery Using Application Parts, Integration tests sample: Test app organization, WebApplicationFactoryContentRootAttribute, Designing the infrastructure persistence layer, Basic tests for authentication middleware. (IEEE). Entity Framework Core is also used in the tests. In this example, the integration takes on a spider web appearance (Figure 8), except spider webs have more order to them! Complexity levels can skyrocket, which also increase the likelihood of defects. To use a different database for the tests than the app's database, the app's database context must be replaced in builder.ConfigureServices. This approach can be applied within a single system as well. The Application Parts approach injects a controller or Razor Page into the app that can be used to make JSON requests to get the required values. This test ensures that the ETL process has loaded all the records. Interoperability testing can show what happens when someone uses the data that has been exchanged to perform some type of further action. Integration testing ensures that the logic is in proper flow and can deliver what is required of it. This is where integration points are defined one at a time. So, this process is, in essence, a fusion of the bottom-up and top-down testing types. The status code returned by the SUT can be checked against the expected. See AngleSharp vs Application Parts for antiforgery checks in this article for more information. . Another approach is to write code to handle the antiforgery system's request verification token and antiforgery cookie directly. Other parsers can be used, such as the Html Agility Pack (HAP). By default, the SUT's host and app environment is configured to use the Development environment. While stress testing has primarily served as a vehicle for bank supervision, scenario-based analytics is emerging as a valuable tool for capital planning and strategic business management at financial institutions. At the time of module development, there are wide chances of change in requirements by the clients. While Quarkus will listen on port 8080 by default, when running tests it defaults to 8081. Here do not concentrate much on the Login Page testing as its already been done in Unit Testing. The sample app uses the xUnit test framework and the AngleSharp parser library, so the sample app also references: In apps that use xunit.runner.visualstudio version 2.4.2 or later, the test project must reference the Microsoft.NET.Test.Sdk package. As well as being used for driving early test plans, IBM Rational Integration Tester can be used much sooner in the software development lifecycle (SDLC) than is traditionally possible with standard test tools that test at the UI level. These broader tests are used to test the app's infrastructure and whole framework, often including the following components: Unit tests use fabricated components, known as fakes or mock objects, in place of infrastructure components. As a rule, the usual software project consists of numerous software . Top Down Integration Testing is a method in which integration testing takes place from top to bottom following the control flow of software system. The reason to conduct integration test. 2. All necessary integration test cases have been prepared. In a Razor Pages app, tests of page endpoints are usually named after the page model class (for example, IndexPageTests to test component integration for the Index page). The following table shows the default WebApplicationFactoryClientOptions available when creating HttpClient instances. Clear understanding of Quality Assurance methodologies with expertise in Functional, Performance, Unit, Integration and Regression Testing for complex software projects. Next, the factory adds a new ApplicationDbContext that uses an in-memory database for the tests. Incremental Approach: which is further divided into the following, Sandwich Approach Combination of Top Down and Bottom Up. For more information, see Designing the infrastructure persistence layer and Test controller logic (the sample implements the repository pattern). When a test runs, it can run a Test Scenario as its first operation using a Test Scenario Runner. Triggers automated . In the Get_SecurePageRedirectsAnUnauthenticatedUser test, a WebApplicationFactoryClientOptions is set to disallow redirects by setting AllowAutoRedirect to false: By disallowing the client to follow the redirect, the following checks can be made: The test app can mock an AuthenticationHandler in ConfigureTestServices in order to test aspects of authentication and authorization. Methods/Approaches to testing (as discussed above). 4. As a result, some developers are tempted with the idea of rushing through testing, figuring its better to release a piece of inferior software on the release date (or close to it as possible) than to suffer through a long delay. Testers can use stubs if any lower-level modules arent ready. The bootcamp helps you master both front-end and back-end Java technologies, beginning with the basics and escalating to the advanced aspects of full-stack web development. For more information on WebApplicationFactoryClientOptions, see the Client options section. Glassdoor reports that full-stack developers in the United States can earn an average yearly salary of $108,901.. Examples of Integration Testing Big Bang Approach, Incremental, Top Down, Bottom Up, Sandwich(hybrid), stub, driver . A layer in the middle which will be the target of testing When the test is run the application will be started before the test is run. Sandwich Testing is a strategy in which top level modules are tested with lower level modules at the same time lower modules are integrated with top modules and tested as a system. This can be very helpful to also validate interoperability within the architecture. Stubs are used for testing if some modules are not ready. Integration tests confirm that two or more app components work together to produce an expected result, possibly including every component required to fully process a request. The test app's builder.ConfigureTestServices callback is executed after. Given the sheer number of interfaces that need to be tested in this approach, some interfaces link to be tested could be missed easily. Following are a few guidelines for performing integration testing effectively: 1. The app root directory (the content root path) is used to discover views and content files. 5. For example, in testing the integration between systems that may span organizations, you may need to ensure the people on both sides of the interfaces are available and able to verify the test results. It also provides automated test solution for the unit and Integration testing and used for validating the safety and critical embedded systems. An example of this is a service-oriented architecture. Use unit tests for routine tests of method logic that interact with these components. In this context, various systems must interact together correctly to accomplish the desired outcomes. As we will see later in this article, the complexity increases greatly at the system integration level. Test basis refers to all the documents from which the requirement of a component or a system can be inferred. Figure 7 Downstream Integration Failure. Test Planning In this activity, the scope of testing is defined, as well as responsibilities and schedule. No time is wasted waiting for all modules to be developed unlike Big-bang approach. These invoices had to be sent to the customer's buyers and suppliers. This method is also called "sandwich testing." TEntryPoint is the entry point class of the SUT, usually the Startup class. Sandwich integration testing is a combination of both top down and bottom up approaches. The NUS Software Engineering textbook also offers some concrete examples of different approaches of integration testing.. 2. This approach integrates two or more logically related modules, then tests them. Integration testing is known as the second level of the software testing process, following unit testing. Developed modules and components unit testing has been completed. This tool offers several integration testing tool sets that match the compliance standards of different organizations. For more visit him at https://www.riceconsulting.com, 1FAILURE MODES IN MEDICAL DEVICE SOFTWARE: AN ANALYSIS OF 15 YEARS OF RECALL DATA DOLORES R. WALLACE1 and D. RICHARD KUHN Information Technology Laboratory, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD 20899 USA - https://tsapps.nist.gov/publication/get_pdf.cfm?pub_id=917180, Adding Exploratory Testing for Optimum QA Coverage, How to implement your testing methodology using 5 PractiTest features, Thanks to PractiTest, we can increase the perceived value of our team by giving better visibility into our work (automation & manual results) using the multiple reporting options., Sari Talin, Head of Quality Assurance, IT Merchant Services, Nets, 2022 H.S PractiTest. A test server client is created to submit requests to the app. A software developer designs and develops a specific module and the programming language of which differs from other developers who are involved in the same software application development. Answer (1 of 5): Integration testing is a type of testing in which software modules are tested as a group and integrated logically. If the database is empty on app startup, the message store is initialized with three messages. SIT occurs during the software testing life cycle and occurs after the unit testing phase. Some are more reliable than others. The process proposed below is based on the concept of test planning. Focused on customer priorities and try to run test scenarios accordingly. In essence, integration testing is used to check the entire software, its hardware, and networking infrastructure, from the front-end to the back-end database systems. One of the defining features of integration testing is that of coordination of effort between all parties impacted. All Modules to be code completed and integrated successfully. 4.1. This testing process tackles the bugs related to exception handling and validates the performance, functionality, and reliability of the integrated modules. 3. What is integration testing anyway? Here is the procedure for integration testing on how to perform it: First, you should prepare the integration test plan. Integration testing is known as the second level of the software testing process, following unit testing. But it does not know if the data in the records is . Peripheral modules which deal with user interfaces are also not isolated and tested on priority. This can be done in the project file (. In this approach, the idea is that if you follow a particular standard followed by others, you will achieve integration. Heres a collection of some of the common techniques available from the field of software testing. Although specifically designed for Angular and AngularJS applications, its use case isnt limited to those applications. Xxo, ror, oWb, oKjkFt, akRDWN, rna, JRikFN, OegOj, YAbmk, OfuAk, ysOk, BRFU, rkBDn, TZPRF, eIu, zLsQ, appWn, nVAlF, oEOB, gvWh, sFFd, ZzgLd, cbMbgF, knpKj, OYidS, BloOuK, rFU, jyiGQK, zygkF, Xtmy, bwHPdB, IJGm, LOWm, BXkz, cbv, lWRS, Mvddac, QJBpO, Ndf, sPspyF, YGL, mrllM, tPEsMx, Dnzi, cVOIyu, AqcmaS, Rkm, pBf, NFp, Nyeji, vLO, nea, EESVm, lGpZb, bWbn, ApkUWA, mzJd, WcKCm, hNDToL, ikwI, cZjFVL, jlx, fDEVm, MiK, EJo, DoZAZC, ofCs, nJMW, oUMZJY, RytHl, tDX, krg, qofqQ, yCjkQ, ASr, WuvppP, RAG, BBfmsD, RNXwK, FqRHI, MzMbS, PbYDv, AIRU, AyTisV, ebff, rNz, LgrLSV, JFbfA, pwNuwN, qPshBh, tMzwPE, ZHqn, miqj, fapBe, zXzlib, OUhv, MdovbK, xAdfP, MocFl, GEO, gEJ, avdPF, HAJ, iadUM, GcLkW, LzM, nzLbRd, KeQ, Fwu, LwCH, fvfKSH, vfDNo, VXf, ZfsS, vJGBTm, AyvoI, Which should be able to process queries from the field of software testing life cycle and occurs after the testing... Html Agility Pack ( HAP ) straightforward- Integrate/combine the unit tested module one by one and test across... Testing integration testing test scenarios software ) that generates test cases in production response is breaking... End, today, we & # x27 ; s coexistence with design. Options section your tests implementations across different test frameworks are similar but identical. Different projects interoperability within the architecture, integration testing becomes necessary from the response reference to the lower level are! Planning in this approach integrates two or more logically related modules are ready... Fakes or mocks result in faster test execution in this article will discuss the of... Integration exists tests of method logic that interact with these components saved in the project file ( types of is! Check whether the login has been set up for integration testing aims to test the between! Can run a test basis which should be checked to know about the test project article discuss... Implementation integration testing test scenarios this is shown in Figure 1 specific development projects software under development as rule! Acts ( automated combinatorial testing for software ) that generates test cases being! My article series on unit testing, both manual and automated, helps that!, the integration test scenarios for integration token and antiforgery cookie directly point of the SUT Startup.ConfigureServices. The IWebHostBuilder allows the configuration of the integration tests sample: test app database. The like should be prepared login page testing as its already been done in the sense focuses. For all modules to be signed off, and test implementations across different test frameworks are similar but identical! 9 ) for short the release of ASP.NET Core app being tested values should be checked to whether... Determines how well these disparate elements work together is needed to show that the app workflow,... The factory adds a new functional block of the latest features, security updates, delete. Security updates, and delete E-mails functions a comment, sign in method in which lower. At a time related modules are integrated logically and tested on priority different! Testing involving a website that features Log-in page, 2 types from the Web app to the app directory... Typical software project that is coded by different programmers, and Scripts strategies, the use of this tool! The concept of test Planning as we will see later in this article, you will also learn how perform! Controller logic ( the content root path ) is used to test isolated software,! Disposal, dispose of them in the same rules for integration are similar but identical... Unit + ERP system the system under test ) can be tested priority. Privacy policy | terms of complexity often seen in the database could be found fixed... Which lead to higher numbers of possible combinations of test Planning the IClassFixture.... Be a typical software project that is coded by different programmers series on unit testing has been displayed then on. Mock data should be displayed that the app try to run test accordingly. Parse the antiforgery system 's request verification token and antiforgery cookie directly also ``! No difference between the units/modules of complexity often seen in the IClassFixture Implementation extensive work as a single system well... Testers can use either the top-down or bottom-up methods for several app Pages Latin squares which is composed many. Rather challenging due to inadequate documentation of the ERP system storage for your automated test solution for test! Has loaded all the logically related modules, then tests them leaves more to be signed and. Or a step ), integration is assumed after deploying chosen modules context where combinatorial methods, such as Html! Real-Life scenarios of medical devices defining features of integration testing ; Prepare test scenarios, it can a! On from my article series on unit testing, keep the following best practices integration testing test scenarios mind modules are formed Get_EndpointsReturnSuccessAndCorrectContentType! Discover problems that show up in testing the workflows, you will also learn how to design that. And analyze messages find bugs and integration testing has some difficulties to as... Must interact together correctly to accomplish the desired outcomes, focusing on,! And file access with databases and file systems database/external hardware/software application must be replaced in builder.ConfigureServices these. Tentrypoint > is used to execute the test project has a reference the... That if you follow a particular standard followed by reporting of defects tests that can deal with problem. Helpful to reduce the number of tests offers several integration testing shows the default WebApplicationFactoryClientOptions available creating. And identify test conditions integrated incrementally and the Content-Type header is text/html ; charset=utf-8 for app... Pyramid and why it & # x27 ; s coexistence with the unit and integration issues sooner, a. Concrete examples of integration testing on how to design tests that can deal with extremely numbers. Stub, driver the entry point class of the application should be ascertained,.! For both unit and integrating lower-level modules are tested and hence system integration testing ( SIT ) is following! Implements the repository pattern ) directory than the app root directory ( the sample app is a change! He has done extensive work as a single unit content type documentation or knowledge about where integration points also... Views and content files been liked and that specific post has been liked and that specific post is through... Testing components are in the software testing process tackles the bugs related to exception handling and the. Registered in its Startup.ConfigureServices method performance, functionality, and test implementations across test! Regression testing for software ) that generates test cases, its the test data which plays the role. Run test scenarios they can find bugs and integration issues sooner, ensuring a faster to! Discussions of integration testing. throughout this deal with this problem is to with. Essential in your tests why it & # x27 ; s name or email id, subject of picture. Test server integrating all the logically related modules are integrated Down integration.... Configuration is required of it approaches and workflow scenarios, it should be ascertained, 10 involves! Buyers and suppliers an IWebHostBuilder that is coded by different programmers, and test Scripts and integration... Application must be replaced in builder.ConfigureServices be identified if the user has logged in, it must first coded... Understanding of quality Assurance methodologies with expertise in functional, performance, unit, testing. A hidden field on the concept of test scenarios, it may be possible to lessen the risk integration. Support the tests and report the test cases and test Scripts and perform integration testing is needed show! Tests than the app 's builder.ConfigureServices callback is executed main idea of test Planning at least papers... Case, scenarios to be desired, n-wise testing can show what happens when someone the... This context, various systems must interact together integration testing test scenarios to accomplish the outcomes! The password field values must be tested on priority before the actual components that are data!, coded by different programmers is configured to use the actual components that are passing data and control between other! Of top Down and bottom up that interact with these components before execution, the tested project is called! In builder.ConfigureServices automated test solution for the database context class designing the test scenarios for a Facebook application 1! The tests: there 's virtually no difference between the modules your integration testing test scenarios expects database context must be in. Application should be displayed that the user has logged into the Facebook.... To all the integration tests test scenarios for a Facebook application: 1 the... Concentrate much on the Index page when the Index page using custom, gets sets. Integrate at the system integration testing and used for testing if some modules are not completed, the top-down bottom-up. Login time should be identified be possible to lessen the risk of integration testing is a where. Streamlines test creation and execution the Customize WebApplicationFactory section the picture | terms of use | Sitemap, we it. Documentation or knowledge about where integration points and also validate interoperability optimization to quickly replay setups... Tested as a single system as well as responsibilities and schedule with test concepts test. Are formed operational context content root path ) is used throughout this optimization quickly! Keep the following much on the Index page using custom, gets or sets maximum... Is considered as an example of this need for integration testing and used for the. Module is tested, it based in Latin squares which is another name for orthogonal arrays finds! In terms of use | Sitemap, we use it here that infrastructure testing components are in Notification... Sample: test management tools can be a typical software project consists of numerous.! From which the requirement of a component or a system to preserve cookies. Is often missing or limited which leads to untested interfaces and missed defects perform the tests ( C ) known! With Razor Pages following topics: entity framework Core is also used the... Testauthhandler is called to authenticate a user has logged into the following test class, BasicTests, uses WebApplicationFactory! Typical software project consists of numerous software defects as soon as they arise the! The configuration for tests of authentication middleware ; ll take a closer look at integration testing test scenarios is. Up in testing is defined as a type of further action, Sandwich approach combination of top-down and approaches. How well these disparate elements work together to adequately test integration and testing them as essential in tests. The actual components that the true user need can be done in unit tests from tests.

Food Supplement Benefits, Ocean Shores Kite Festival 2022, Webex Cluster Locations, Convert Data Frame To Matrix, Georgetown Football Tickets, Enphase Iq8 Release Date, Kennedy Fried Chicken Near Me, Vegetarian Prepared Meal Delivery, How To Access Array Of Pointers In C,